Montauk Yacht Club

The resort offers 106 guest rooms and historic villas with private patios or balconies overlooking Lake Montauk. Each room features interior design that bridges classic East Coast architecture with well-appointed details such as Aesop bath products and one of the hotel's signature robes available for purchase. Rooms include walkout access to the beach in select categories, and the property recently completed a full renovation under Proper Hospitality management.

The on-site Ocean Club restaurant & bar is led by Chef Jarad McCarroll and offers menus spotlighting just-caught seafood, local produce, and shareable fare cooked over a wood-and-coal fire. The restaurant provides an open-concept kitchen framed by waterfront views, with indoor and outdoor seating available seasonally. Guests can also visit the all-day takeaway café and the poolside bar for drinks and snacks.

The property has three swimming pools - two outdoor and one indoor - plus a private beach with chairs and personalized awnings. Guests have access to padel courts, tennis courts, complimentary bicycles, yoga classes, and a state-of-the-art fitness center. Complimentary electric boat cruises with Captain Paul depart daily, and the hotel offers stand-up paddleboards and kayaks for use on Lake Montauk.

Montauk Yacht Club sits on 16 acres of waterfront on Star Island and operates the Hamptons' largest marina with 228 wet slips that can accommodate vessels from small day cruisers up to 300-foot superyachts. The resort is minutes from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, Camp Hero State Park, and the Montauk Farmers Market. Guests can use the hotel's house car for transportation to town, and the property has electric vehicle charging stations and valet parking.

The resort is family-friendly with a dedicated kids' pool, a children's play area with a sand field, hammocks, and cornhole, plus complimentary use of paddleboards and bikes. Pets are welcome: the hotel provides pet baskets, pet bowls, and dog beds upon request (as noted in guest reviews). Staff members such as Tim Markman, Director of Guest Experience, have been praised for equipping rooms with dog amenities within minutes of arrival.

Accommodations: 106 rooms & villas with Lake Montauk views

Dining: Ocean Club restaurant with wood-and-coal fire cooking

Recreation: Private beach, three pools, padel & tennis courts

Marina: 228 wet slips, largest in the Hamptons

Wellness: Complimentary yoga, electric boat cruises, fitness center

Family: Kids' pool, playground, complimentary paddleboards

Pet Policy: Dog beds, bowls, and baskets on arrival